Motor power
625W
Vitamix 5-Speed Immersion Blender
$164.99 4.7 (4,700)
vs Breville Control Grip — 280W
Decisive if you're blending frozen fruit, fibrous vegetables, or dense soups regularly
Vitamix vs Breville Immersion Blender: Where $100 Goes
Researched by Forge
·3 min read
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure.
VS
The Vitamix 5-Speed and Breville Control Grip are both well-reviewed, but they're built around completely different assumptions about what matters. Here's which one is actually worth your money.
The data behind that call is less obvious than it looks. A 345W gap sounds decisive, but the Breville has real advantages the wattage chart doesn't show. Here's what actually separates them.
Continuous run time
Up to 3 minutes (Bon Appétit: 'most competitors limited to 1 minute')
Vitamix 5-Speed Immersion Blender
$164.99 4.7 (4,700)
vs Breville Control Grip — Not specified
Longer run time means you finish big batches of soup without stopping to let the motor cool
Splatter control
Anti-suction technology prevents wandering in jars (Bon Appétit)
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
$149.95 4.5 (4,000)
vs Vitamix 5S — LED-guided smooth acceleration reduces splatter (Shouldit)
Anti-suction matters most for countertop jar blending; smooth acceleration helps in pots
Cookware safety
- Vitamix 5S
- Bell guard rated scratch-free for nonstick and enameled cookware (Bon Appétit)
- Breville Control Grip
- Plastic rim on blade guard protects nonstick and enameled cast iron (Bon Appétit)
Both protect delicate cookware – a real differentiator from all-metal guards like Mueller
Included attachments
Blending jar with lid, chopping bowl, whisk included (Bon Appétit)
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
$149.95 4.5 (4,000)
vs Vitamix 5S — None at base price; whisk and chopper sold separately (Bon Appétit)
Attachment value is real money – Breville's kit is functional and well-built per Bon Appétit testing
Weight
Not specified (lighter than 3.2 lbs per category norms)
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
$149.95 4.5 (4,000)
vs Vitamix 5S — 3.2 lbs
Matters if you're holding the shaft steady in a pot for 90+ seconds; fatigue is real at 3 lbs
The verdict above holds for most readers. Two situations genuinely flip it.
By your situation
Which one fits your situation?
Blending hot soup directly in the pot, daily
625W and a 3-minute run time means no stalling mid-batch. r/cookware users consistently recommend it for this.
Vitamix 5-Speed Immersion Blender
$164.99 4.7 (4,700)
Smoothies and sauces a few times a week, want attachments ready
280W handles routine tasks without stalling, and the included chopper and whisk save you from buying extras separately.
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
$149.95 4.5 (4,000)
Blending frozen fruit for smoothies
The Breville's 280W stalls on frozen fruit more than the Vitamix's 625W motor, per Shouldit testing.
Vitamix 5-Speed Immersion Blender
$164.99 4.7 (4,700)
Budget-conscious, nonstick pots, occasional use
Lower price, cookware-safe plastic rim guard, and all-in-one attachment kit beats paying Vitamix prices for light use.
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
$149.95 4.5 (4,000)
Before you commit, here's what the reviews couldn't tell us.
- Does the Vitamix immersion blender shaft fit in a standard pot?
- The Vitamix shaft measures 17.5 x 3 inches overall. The shaft diameter and bell guard are designed to fit standard stockpots, though the 3.2 lb weight means you'll feel it over a long puree session. No source we reviewed flagged clearance issues with standard cookware.
- Can the Breville Control Grip handle hot soups directly in the pot?
- Yes. The plastic rim on the Breville's blade guard protects enameled and nonstick cookware, per Bon Appétit testing. The 280W motor is adequate for most pureed soups, though it takes more up-and-down passes to get a consistent texture compared to higher-powered models.
- Why does Vitamix cost more if it doesn't include any attachments?
- The price premium reflects the motor and continuous run time, not the kit. At 625W and a 3-minute run ceiling, it's the most powerful immersion blender tested by Shouldit, where it's listed as the Upgrade Pick. If you're comparing total cost for a whisk and chopper, the Breville's included set makes the gap narrower than sticker prices suggest.
- Which blender is quieter?
- Bon Appétit noted that the Vitamix is unusually quiet for its power output, which is notable given 625W motors typically run loud. Shouldit measured the Vitamix at 85 dB in their testing – louder than the Braun MQ5 at 65 dB – but a direct Vitamix-vs-Breville decibel comparison wasn't available in any source we reviewed.
- Is the Breville Control Grip a good 'buy it for life' choice?
- The Breville comes with a 1-year warranty, which is short compared to Braun's longer coverage on the MultiQuick line. No Reddit threads on r/BuyItForLife specifically endorsed the Breville Control Grip for longevity – that community heavily favors Braun. If long-term durability is the primary goal, the Breville is a capable daily driver but not the consensus BIFL pick.
Vitamix 5-Speed Immersion Blender
Amazon
4.7(4,700 reviews)
- Power:
- 625W
- Speeds:
- 5 speeds (LED display)
- Weight:
- 3.2 lbs
- Dimensions:
- 17.5 x 3 inches
- Attachments:
- None included (sold separately)
- Blade Guard:
- Bell guard, scratch-free design
- Max Continuous Run:
- 3 minutes
Breville Control Grip Immersion Blender (BSB510XL)
Amazon
4.5(4,000 reviews)
- Power:
- 280W
- Speeds:
- 15 speeds
- Warranty:
- 1 year
- Attachments:
- Blending jar with lid, chopping bowl with blade, whisk
- Blade Guard:
- Plastic rim protects delicate cookware
- Anti Suction:
- Anti-suction blending technology
- Blending Depth:
- 8 inches
Related articles
