Price
vs Modkat XL — $189.95
A $150 gap is hard to justify unless the extra features solve a specific problem you have
Top Entry Litter Box: Modkat XL vs. the $40 Box
Researched by Sage
·4 min read
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure.
VS
Top entry litter boxes solve one problem better than any other design: litter scatter. But the gap between a $40 top-entry box and a $190 one is large enough that it deserves an honest look at what you actually get.
Here is the evidence behind that call.
Review base and trust
4.5★ across 33,900 Amazon reviews
vs Modkat XL — 4.4★ across 1,200 Amazon reviews (Amazon's Choice)
More reviews means more known failure modes – the large sample tells you what breaks and when
Litter scatter prevention
- Large TE Hooded
- Top-entry only – cats shake paws on lid before exiting, virtually eliminates front scatter
- Modkat XL
- Top-entry mode offers same scatter control; front-entry mode does not
Both designs eliminate front scatter in top-entry mode – this is the whole point of buying either
Leakproof base
Seamless leakproof base prevents any urine seepage
Modkat XL Configurable Litter Box (Top or Front Entry)
$189.95 4.4 (1,200)
vs Large TE Hooded — Standard plastic base – no seamless seal specified
If your cat sprays high or misses the wall, a leaking base soaks into flooring – the seamless base prevents that entirely
Entry flexibility
Configurable: switches between top-entry and front-entry modes
Modkat XL Configurable Litter Box (Top or Front Entry)
$189.95 4.4 (1,200)
vs Large TE Hooded — Top entry only – fixed design
Useful if you add a senior or arthritic cat later who cannot jump – front-entry mode makes the box usable without buying another box
Ongoing consumable costs
Standard litter only – no proprietary consumables
vs Modkat XL — Requires proprietary Type C reusable tarp liner – adds ongoing cost
Proprietary liners lock you into repurchase cycles; standard litter is available anywhere
The verdict above holds for most readers. Two situations flip parts of it.
By your situation
Which one fits your situation?
Cat sprays walls or consistently misses
The seamless leakproof base on the Modkat XL is the specific fix for urine that pools and seeps under a standard base.
Modkat XL Configurable Litter Box (Top or Front Entry)
$189.95 4.4 (1,200)
Multi-cat home, just need scatter control
At $39.99, you can afford multiple units to meet the N+1 rule without breaking the budget.
Large Top-Entry Enclosed Hooded Litter Box
$39.99 4.5 (33,900)
Dog also in the household
Top-entry design blocks dog access by default – both boxes handle this, but the Hooded does it for $150 less.
Large Top-Entry Enclosed Hooded Litter Box
$39.99 4.5 (33,900)
Might add a senior cat in the future
Switching to front-entry mode means you do not need to buy a replacement box when jumping becomes difficult.
Modkat XL Configurable Litter Box (Top or Front Entry)
$189.95 4.4 (1,200)
Before you buy either, there are a few things the available data cannot tell you.
- Is a top entry litter box suitable for senior or arthritic cats?
- No, a pure top-entry design is not suitable for senior or arthritic cats. Jumping in and out of a top-entry box requires mobility that cats with joint pain or arthritis may not have. The Large Top-Entry Hooded box is explicitly noted in its listing as requiring cats to be comfortable jumping. If your cat has mobility issues, a low-entry design (like the PetKit PuraMax 2's low entrance) is a safer option. The Modkat XL partially addresses this because it can be reconfigured to front-entry mode, which removes the jumping requirement.
- Do I need more than one litter box if I have two cats?
- Yes, veterinarians and feline behaviorists recommend the N+1 rule: one box per cat plus one extra. For two cats, that means three boxes. PetMD, Purina, and MudBay all confirm this. Some cats refuse to share, and territorial guarding of a single box causes litter box avoidance. At $39.99 each, buying three of the Large Top-Entry Hooded boxes is still cheaper than one Modkat XL.
- What litter works with a top entry box?
- Both boxes work with standard clumping litter. The top-entry design actually helps with litter tracking because cats shake their paws on the lid surface before exiting. Neither box requires proprietary litter. The Modkat XL does require proprietary Type C tarp liners for the base, but litter itself is unrestricted. Avoid crystal or pellet litters if the raking mechanisms of any automatic add-on are involved, but for these manual boxes, any clumping litter works.
- Can the Modkat XL fit inside a furniture enclosure?
- Possibly, but it depends on the enclosure. The Modkat XL has a sleek modern design specifically described in its listing as working without a furniture enclosure. Standard furniture enclosures like the Feandrea (33.5 x 19 x 19.5 in) have fixed interior dimensions that may not accommodate the Modkat XL's footprint plus the top-entry lid clearance needed for a cat to jump in and out. Measure your enclosure's interior height carefully before assuming a top-entry box fits inside it.
- How does top-entry compare to automatic litter boxes for scatter control?
- Top-entry manual boxes and automatic boxes solve scatter through completely different mechanisms. Top-entry boxes eliminate front scatter because cats enter and exit through the top, shaking paws on the lid. Automatic boxes like the Litter-Robot 4 use a rotating globe to sift waste but do not specifically eliminate scatter from entry and exit. If scatter is your primary complaint and you do not want the complexity, ongoing costs, or failure modes of an automatic unit, a top-entry manual box is the simpler and cheaper fix.
Large Top-Entry Enclosed Hooded Litter Box
Amazon
4.5(33,900 reviews)
- Type:
- Manual top-entry enclosed
- Entry:
- Top entry
- Design:
- Hooded/enclosed
- Includes:
- Scoop
- Dog Proof:
- Yes
- Scatter Control:
- Yes — top entry eliminates front scatter
Modkat XL Configurable Litter Box (Top or Front Entry)
Amazon
4.4(1,200 reviews)
- Base:
- Seamless leakproof base
- Type:
- Manual premium non-automatic
- Badge:
- Amazon's Choice
- Entry:
- Configurable — top or front
- Liner:
- Reusable tarp liner
- Extras:
- Sifting scoop, 2 bamboo charcoal filters
Related articles
